XMRV - Will the Baby Be Thrown Out With the Bath Water?

In 2009, "Science Magazine" published a newlycause or cure, and the XMRV discovery gave the
released paper from Whittemore Petersonestimated 17  millions of sufferers hope for the
Institute about the existence of XMRV, (whichfirst time in many years.
stands for xenotropic murine leukemia virusNow, a year later, the mud slinging has begun with
related virus,) which looked to be a causativesmall studies that seem designed to do nothing
agent in CFS, Fibromyalgia, Prostate Cancer andmore than cast doubt on the original work at
several other neuro-immune disorders.WPI.  With the close connections that have been
The race was on.drawn between CFS/ME, Fibromyalgia, RA, MS,
All around the world there were doors opened forAutism, chronic Lyme disease (Oooh, yes we
research scientists to apply this remarkablehave been told by the dark robed priests of the
discovery and try to find better diagnostic tools,IDSA that there is no such thing as chronic Lyme
better treatment and of course - the greatdisease!) by top researchers who have been
career maker - finding a cure.written about elsewhere in this blog, one must
Somehow, I am willing to bet that the excitementquestion the validity of the mud-slingers, and
surrounding the original research had more to dowonder if continued funding will allow WPI and
with the potential impact on prostate cancerother reputable research firms to solve the
patients.mystery of XMRV - amazingly only the third type
Why?of virus known to mankind at this time.
Well, if you aren't familiar with "Osler's Web: InsideSo little is known just yet, but enough for some
The Labyrinth of the Chronic Fatigue Syndromemedical doctors who are themselves infected with
Epidemic", then perhaps you are unaware of thechronic Lyme to consider jumping ship altogether
government scandal that was exposed by authorand dividing Lyme sufferers into those who
Hillary Johnson in 1996 proving fraud to the tunerespond to antibiotics - those without XMRV, and
of many millions of dollars that had beenthose who don't respond to antibiotics, don't have
earmarked from Congress to the CDC toLyme and have XMRV instead which would
research CFS/ME, but had been applied to otherexplain quite a bit about the vast differences
programs.  This involved cooked books and lyingbetween treatment responses.
to Congress amongst many other crimes by anOne such doctor is Jamie Deckoff-Jones, MD who
entire division at CDC.tells her story convincingly at
Thankfully those funds have been accounted forIt has been so exciting to think that perhaps
and new programs put together under newXMRV would give chronic Lyme, CFS/ME,
management at the CDC.Fibromyalgia and other chronic illnesses some hope
So, up until the announcement last year by WPI,for future help.  But it appears that the baby
there had been very few breakthroughs regardingmay be getting thrown out with the bath water.